The Science Behind a Perfect Tomato Soup
Butter, unlike oil, caramelizes beautifully during cooking, imparting a rich, nutty flavor to the soup. The addition of carrot purée introduces an earthy sweetness that balances the acidity of tomatoes while contributing to a creamy texture without relying heavily on cream. A dash of baking soda can help neutralize any excessive acidity in the dish.
My journey with Serious Eats began on a rainy day when I was yearning for a comforting bowl of tomato soup. Many recipes I encountered featured ingredients like sherry, Parmesan cheese, and caramelized onions—delicious as they may be—but they didn’t evoke the nostalgic flavors from my childhood. That evening, all I craved was something straightforward and hearty; thankfully, Nordstrom’s tomato basil soup fit the bill perfectly.
While it contained plenty of carrots, I believed their sweetness would primarily serve to counterbalance the tartness of canned tomatoes—and I was right! Once blended into a purée, they provided not only creaminess but also freshness that revitalized the tomatoes. This discovery happened over nine years ago and has since become a staple in my kitchen.
Before Kenji’s 15-Minute Creamy Tomato Soup (and its ultra-quick five-minute variant), my go-to recipe remained this one from Nordstrom. Although I’ve grown fond of quick cooking methods over time, there’s something special about that first encounter with Serious Eats that lingers in my memory.
Given my profession revolves around indulging in an array of baked goods—from cookies to cakes—I’m always eager for ways to incorporate more vegetables into my meals. This is precisely what Nordstrom’s tomato soup accomplishes!
As someone who enjoys precision in cooking, I took it upon myself to refine some aspects of this recipe for consistency. By converting ingredient measurements into weights—not because tomato soup demands exactitude but because vague terms like “large” can lead to varying results—I aimed for uniformity across batches.
Some readers found the original version bland or overly carrot-flavored; however, others loved it just as it was! By quantifying ingredients accurately—like carrots and onions—we can achieve that perfect balance where flavors are both vibrant yet mellow.
In place of olive oil used in the original recipe, I opted for butter which adds depth through browning during vegetable sautéing—a nod towards classic Campbell’s flavor profiles that have long inspired me.
Once you notice some lovely browning at the bottom of your pot after sautéing vegetables for about 15 minutes add your canned tomatoes along with chicken stock—homemade if possible or low-sodium store-bought will do just fine!
While initial simmering times suggested by others ranged from 20-45 minutes; based on experience I’ve found extending this time yields better results—about twice as long is ideal! With such large quantities (135 fluid ounces!), rushing leads only to watery outcomes which some reviewers noted previously.
Longer simmering not only mellows out any overpowering carrot taste but also tenderizes them further resulting in an even creamier purée once blended!
Since acidity levels vary depending on your choice brand/type canned tomatoes used; adding baking soda becomes essential if needed! If you find your broth too sharp or acidic after tasting simply sprinkle in ¼ teaspoon baking soda—it will fizz initially due CO2 release so stir well until bubbles dissipate before retasting again—you may need another pinch depending on preference!
When ready it’s time for blending: use an immersion blender directly within pot or let cool slightly before transferring batches carefully into countertop blenders (to avoid lid popping due steam buildup). Straining isn’t necessary here—the cooked veggies create their own wonderfully smooth texture!
I’ve reduced actual heavy cream usage by half—not necessarily aiming at lighter fare—but rather preferring richness paired alongside gooey grilled cheese sandwiches instead! Feel free though if you desire extra creaminess—or thin down with additional stock according personal preference regarding consistency desired!
Finally season generously using salt/pepper/cayenne adjusting amounts based taste buds’ needs while finishing off with fresh basil right before serving—a little goes far without overwhelming other flavors present within dish itself!
This recipe yields approximately twelve cups making enough servings suitable either feeding large gatherings/families throughout rainy weekends ahead—or freezing leftovers easily without hesitation once tasted firsthand—you’ll understand why cutting back isn’t tempting at all!
Thick and Creamy Tomato Soup Recipe
Ingredients: - 4 ounces unsalted butter (1 stick; 114g)
- 4 large carrots (1 pound; 455g), diced
- 2 medium yellow onions (1 pound; 455g), diced
- 3 cans whole tomatoes (28-ounce each; total weight: approx.795g), roughly crushed by hand
- 4 cups homemade or low-sodium chicken stock
- Optional: Up To Additional Baking Soda As Needed
- Optional: Heavy Cream For Richness (8 ounces = approx.,225g) Salt/Pepper/Cayenne To Taste
Instructions:
1) In A Large Stainless Steel Pot Melt Butter Over Medium Heat Until Foaming Then Add Carrots & Onions Cooking Until Browned At Bottom (~15 Minutes).
2) Stir In Tomatoes Followed By Chicken Stock Continuing To Cook While Occasionally Stirring Until Mixture Thickens (~90 Minutes). Adjust Heat As Necessary Maintaining Gentle Simmer Throughout Process.
3) Taste Broth Adding Baking Soda If Too Sharp/Acidic Stirring Well Before Retasting Again.
4) Purée Using Immersion Blender Or Allow Cooling Slightly Before Transferring Into Countertop Blender For Smooth Consistency Achieved!
5) Incorporate Heavy Cream Season With Salt/Pepper/Cayenne According Preference Rewarm Prior Serving & Finish Off With Fresh Basil Just Before Enjoyment!
6) Store Leftovers In Sealed Non-Reactive Containers Refrigerated Up To One Week Or Frozen Six Months Without Compromise Quality Retained Over Time.
Special Equipment Needed:
Large stainless steel pot & immersion blender/countertop blender
Notes:
Vegetable sizes are subjective so feel free adjust accordingly based personal preferences while following general guidelines provided above ensuring delicious outcome every single time enjoyed together around table shared amongst loved ones alike!